The 7 Best Squirrel Baits That Actually Work (2024 Guide)

I’ve tested dozens of squirrel baits, and these seven actually deliver results in 2024.

Kaput’s 5lb and 25lb ground squirrel formulas pack a one-two punch with Diphacinone and Imidacloprid – they’re my top picks for serious infestations. Neogen’s 950 Lure and 116352 Ground Squirrel Bait offer solid alternatives, while Squirrel Butter Paste and Jelly Paste work great in traps.

Don’t forget a proper bait station like the Wilco 100046603 – it’s essential for safety and effectiveness.

Look, squirrels are crafty little devils, but these baits will help you take back your yard. Stick around to discover exactly how to maximize your success with each option.

Essential Insights

• Kaput Ground Squirrel Bait (25lb version) offers the most effective dual-action formula with Diphacinone for large-scale infestations.
• Wilco Ground Squirrel Bait Station combined with anticoagulant baits provides a safe, weather-resistant solution with high user satisfaction.
• Neogen 116352 Ground Squirrel Bait’s fish-flavored formula shows consistent results within three weeks of regular application.
• Weather-resistant Squirrel Butter Paste Bait works effectively in various conditions and is ideal for targeted trapping applications.
• Bulk purchases of anticoagulant baits (25lb bags) provide the best cost-effectiveness for long-term squirrel control.

Kaput Ground Squirrel Bait – Kills Ground Squirrels – 5lb.

For property owners battling persistent ground squirrel invasions, Kaput Ground Squirrel Bait offers a potent solution with its dual-action formula containing Diphacinone and Imidacloprid. Let’s be real – those pesky squirrels won’t evict themselves from your property.

This EPA-approved bait comes in easy-to-use granules. Just dump about 1/4 to 1/2 cup down active burrows. Yeah, it’s that simple. But don’t expect overnight miracles – you’re looking at 2-6 weeks for results.

Key points to remember:

• 5-pound container covers multiple burrows
• Works on both squirrels and their annoying flea roommates
• Requires consistent reapplication (because squirrels aren’t exactly known for their cooperation)

Pro Tip: Use bait stations to keep other critters from throwing a surprise party at your rodent buffet.

The mixed reviews (3.6/5 stars) tell us one thing: results vary. But hey, when it works, it really works. And at #151 in Pest Control Baits, it’s clearly doing something right.

Best For: Property owners and farmers dealing with persistent ground squirrel infestations who need a long-term solution and are willing to wait several weeks for results.

Pros:

• Dual-action formula targets both squirrels and their fleas
• Easy application method with simple pour-and-go instructions
• EPA-approved and covers multiple burrows with 5-pound quantity

Cons:

• Long waiting period (2-6 weeks) before seeing results
• Inconsistent effectiveness based on customer reviews
• Packaging issues reported with potential product spillage during shipping

Kaput Ground Squirrel Bait – Kills Ground Squirrels – 25lb.

Professional pest controllers and property owners battling extensive ground squirrel infestations will find Kaput Ground Squirrel Bait an effective solution. This 25-pound powerhouse comes loaded with Diphacinone and Imidacloprid – fancy words for “squirrels’ worst nightmare.” You’ll notice those pesky rodents starting to disappear within 2-6 weeks.

Here’s what makes this bait worth your money:

• Takes care of both squirrels and their flea roommates
• Works great in bait stations (yes, you’ll want those)
• Squirrels actually do the work for you by taking it back to their burrows

Pro Tip: Don’t waste time with those “natural” solutions like peppermint oil. If you’ve got a serious squirrel situation, this is your nuclear option.

Just remember – this isn’t a buffet for the whole animal kingdom. Use bait stations and follow the instructions. Your neighbor’s cat will thank you.

Best For: Professional pest controllers and property managers dealing with severe ground squirrel infestations who need a powerful, long-term solution.

Pros:

• Highly effective at eliminating both ground squirrels and their fleas within 2-6 weeks
• Squirrels carry bait back to burrows, helping to eliminate entire colonies
• More cost-effective than trapping for large-scale infestations

Cons:

• Requires careful handling and proper bait stations to protect non-target animals
• Takes several weeks to see full results
• Higher upfront cost compared to other control methods

Neogen 950 Squirrel Lure, Brown

Homeowners seeking a non-toxic solution to their squirrel problems will find Neogen 950 Squirrel Lure worth evaluating. It’s made with food-grade ingredients, so you won’t have to worry about harming pets or wildlife when using it in your live traps.

Let’s be real though – this lure’s performance is about as consistent as a squirrel’s attention span. Some folks caught multiple bushy-tailed bandits their first year. Others watched in frustration as squirrels used their traps as springboards to raid bird feeders. Classic squirrel move.

Key Points to Evaluate:

• Works best when paired with pumpkin seeds (don’t ask us why)
• Rain will dissolve it faster than your motivation to catch squirrels
• Can be tricky to apply – prepare for some sticky situations

*Pro Tip: Save yourself some cash and try good old crunchy peanut butter first. Several users reported better results with this grocery store solution than with the fancy lure.*

Best For: Homeowners looking for a non-toxic squirrel trapping solution who are willing to experiment with different baiting methods and have patience for mixed results.

Pros:

• Made with safe, food-grade ingredients that won’t harm animals
• Can be effective when combined with other baits like pumpkin seeds
• Specifically designed for live trapping of squirrels

Cons:

• Inconsistent effectiveness compared to simple alternatives like peanut butter
• Poor weather resistance – dissolves in rain and dries out in heat
• Difficult to apply and handle in traps

Neogen 116352 Home Pest Control Products Ground Squirrel Bait

Ground squirrel infestations meet their match with Neogen 116352’s fish-flavored bait, featuring the active ingredient diphacinone at .005%. This weather-resistant bait means business – just pour it directly into those pesky ground squirrel holes and watch the magic happen.

You’ll need some patience with this one. Start with daily applications, then scale back to every few days once you notice less rodent activity. Most users report seeing results within 3 weeks – because apparently, these squirrels like to take their sweet time deciding to leave your property.

Key Points:

• Hot-extruded formula holds up against outdoor elements
• Fish-flavored grain mix that squirrels can’t resist
• Works specifically on California Ground Squirrels

*Pro Tip: Keep this stuff away from other wildlife – it’s not exactly picky about what tries to eat it. And for heaven’s sake, don’t touch it with bare hands. Those squirrels might be pests, but you don’t want to join their party.*

Best For: Property owners dealing specifically with California ground squirrel infestations who need a long-lasting, weather-resistant bait solution.

Pros:

• Weather-resistant formula stays effective in outdoor conditions
• Fish-flavored grain mix is highly attractive to target pests
• Shows significant results within 3 weeks of consistent application

Cons:

• May attract and harm non-target wildlife species
• Requires careful handling due to toxicity concerns
• Takes several weeks of consistent application to see results

Squirrel Butter Paste Bait (8 Oz) for Squirrels & Chipmunks

Wildlife enthusiasts seeking a specialized bait will find Squirrel Butter Paste an intriguing alternative to traditional peanut butter. This Wisconsin-crafted formula claims to be more enticing than your average jar of Skippy – though let’s just say the jury’s still out on that one.

You’ll get an 8 oz jar of sweet-scented paste that’s supposed to work like catnip for squirrels and chipmunks. It’s weather-resistant and works in both live and lethal traps.

Pro Tips:

• Smear a small amount in the back of your trap (and yes, wear gloves unless you want to smell like squirrel candy)
• Don’t get discouraged if it doesn’t work immediately – some users swear by it while others went running back to good old peanut butter
• Works best when targeting red squirrels, gray squirrels, and chipmunks specifically

*Reality check: Your results may vary wildly. Some folks catch multiple critters in days; others end up with nothing but an expensive jar of nutty paste.*

Best For: Property owners and wildlife managers looking for a specialized bait solution to trap squirrels and chipmunks, particularly in areas where traditional baits haven’t been effective.

Pros:

• Weather-resistant formula that maintains effectiveness in various conditions
• Professionally crafted by animal scientists in Wisconsin
• Convenient 8 oz jar with easy application method

Cons:

• More expensive than traditional peanut butter alternatives
• Inconsistent results reported by users
• May not be more effective than simple peanut butter for some situations

Wilco 100046603 Ground Squirrel Bait Station,Green

The Wilco 100046603 bait station offers a secure and effective solution for those dealing with persistent ground squirrel problems. Made from tough green plastic, this station keeps your bait fresh while keeping kids and pets safe. You’ll appreciate the no-assembly-required design – because who needs another DIY project?

Key features that make this station worth your money:

• Child-resistant lid (those little rascals won’t get in)
• Compact 3-inch size that won’t mess up your lawn
• Professional-grade durability that’ll last for seasons

Pro Tip: Place these stations 30-40 feet apart near squirrel activity zones for maximum impact.

With a solid 4.4-star rating from nearly 500 users, it’s clear this thing works. Sure, the price might make you wince a bit, but it’s cheaper than replacing your garden for the fifth time. Just watch out for that fill cap – it can be a bit finicky when loading bait.

Best For: Homeowners and property managers dealing with persistent ground squirrel problems who need a safe, durable solution that won’t endanger pets or children.

Pros:

• Child-resistant design keeps bait secure from kids and non-target animals
• No assembly required, making it ready to use right out of the box
• High durability with weather-resistant construction for long-term use

Cons:

• Relatively high price point compared to simpler trapping solutions
• Fill cap design can be problematic when loading bait
• May require multiple stations for effective coverage, increasing overall cost

Squirrel Jelly Paste Bait for Live Trapping (8 Oz)

Let’s be honest – the reviews are about as mixed as a squirrel’s winter food cache. While some users strike out completely, others manage to catch everything but squirrels. Go figure.

Here’s what you need to know:

• Slap some paste on a cracker and place it in your trap
• Wear gloves (unless you enjoy smelling like squirrel candy)
• Works in both lethal and live traps
• Holds up in rain or shine

Look, it’s not perfect. But if you’re tired of watching squirrels raid your bird feeders while giving you the side-eye, it’s worth a shot. Just keep your receipt – you might need it.

Best For: Homeowners and property managers looking for a weather-resistant bait option to trap squirrels and chipmunks, though success rates may vary.

Pros:

• Weather-resistant formula that stays effective in rain or dry conditions
• Versatile usage in both lethal and live traps
• Easy to apply with simple cracker-based application method

Cons:

• Inconsistent effectiveness with mixed success rates reported by users
• May attract unwanted animals like rats instead of target species
• Some users report complete lack of attraction for squirrels despite marketing claims

Factors to Consider When Choosing Squirrel Baits

Let me tell you what really matters when you’re picking out squirrel bait – it’s not just about grabbing whatever looks good. I’ll show you five key factors that’ll make or break your squirrel control success, from keeping your pets safe to making sure your bait can handle a downpour. Whether you’re dealing with pesky grey squirrels in your attic or trying to protect your garden, choosing the right bait will save you time, money, and a whole lot of frustration.

Safety and Pet Protection

Safety considerations should be your top priority when selecting squirrel baits, especially if you have pets or children around your property. Let’s face it – nobody wants their curious pup or toddler getting into something they shouldn’t. That’s why I’m deadly serious about this part.

Here’s what you absolutely must look for:

• Child-resistant packaging (because kids are surprisingly clever)
• Bait stations with tamper-proof features (trust me, they’re worth every penny)
• Non-toxic formulations (your cat will thank you)

Pro Tip: Always check local regulations before buying any bait. Some areas restrict certain ingredients – and you don’t want a fine on top of your squirrel problem.

I can’t stress this enough: wear gloves when handling bait. Sure, you might feel silly putting on gloves to deal with some squirrel snacks, but it’s better than explaining a rash to your doctor. And those bait stations? They’re not just fancy squirrel restaurants – they’re essential safety equipment that keeps the bait away from everything except your target pests.

Remember: If it’s not pet-safe, it’s not worth the risk. Period.

Bait Form and Application

Choosing between different bait forms comes down to more than just personal preference – it’s about matching the right type to your specific squirrel situation. Let’s cut through the fluff and get straight to what actually works.

For those pesky burrow-dwellers, I’ll tell you right now: granules and powders are your best friends. Just dump them right into those holes (yes, it’s really that simple). But don’t get cocky – you’ll want a bait station to keep that stuff from blowing all over your yard like confetti.

Here’s what you need to know about each form:

• Granules: Perfect for burrows. Easy to measure. Kind of like squirrel trail mix, if you will.
• Powders: Great coverage, but can be messy. Pro tip: Use on calm days unless you enjoy wearing squirrel bait.
• Pastes: Stick around longer than your ex. Excellent for traps and won’t wash away in rain.

Weather matters more than you think. That fancy powder bait won’t do you much good if it turns into soup during the first drizzle. For wet climates, stick with pastes – they’re like the all-weather tires of the bait world.

Target Species Specificity

With squirrels, one size definitely doesn’t fit all. You wouldn’t wear your neighbor’s shoes, so why would you use a generic bait for different squirrel species? Trust me – that’s a rookie mistake I’ve seen too many times.

Let’s get specific about your furry targets:

• Red squirrels need different bait formulations than grays (Yeah, they’re picky like that)
• Ground squirrels won’t always go for tree squirrel baits
• Each species has their preferred “menu items” – respect that

Pro Tip: Match the bait type to your exact pest. You’ll see results in 2-6 weeks instead of waiting forever.

The science behind this is pretty straightforward. Different anticoagulants work better on specific species. I’m not trying to turn you into a rodent scientist, but here’s what matters:

• Granules work better for some species
• Others prefer paste baits
• Some only respond to powder formulations

Don’t waste time and money on the wrong bait. I’ve seen people throw everything but the kitchen sink at their squirrel problem. Be smarter. Target your specific unwanted guests, and you’ll get way better results.

Weather Resistance Properties

Weather resistance stands out as one of the most overlooked factors in squirrel bait selection. Let’s face it – nothing’s more frustrating than watching your expensive bait turn into a soggy mess after the first drizzle. I’ve been there, and I’ll help you avoid that rookie mistake.

Here’s what you need to know about weather-resistant baits:

• Look for “all-weather” formulas that specifically mention rain resistance
• Avoid loose grain baits unless they’re in a covered station
• Choose solid block baits for maximum durability

Pro Tip: The best baits maintain their appeal in temperatures from 20°F to 100°F

Don’t waste your money on cheap baits that’ll dissolve faster than your New Year’s resolutions. Weather-resistant options might cost more upfront, but you’ll save big on replacements. Trust me – I’ve learned this lesson the hard way.

Key benefits of weather-resistant baits:

• Less frequent replacement needed
• Consistent attraction power
• Better overall pest control results
• Lower long-term costs

*Pro Tip: Position baits under natural cover when possible to extend their lifespan even further*

Cost Vs Coverage Area

Between cost and coverage area lies an essential balance that can make or break your squirrel control budget. I’ve seen too many people blow their money on tiny bags of bait that wouldn’t cover a postage stamp – don’t be that person.

Here’s what you need to know about getting the most bang for your buck:

• Smaller bait packages might seem cheaper upfront, but you’ll end up spending more when you have to keep buying them. Trust me, those pesky squirrels aren’t going anywhere soon.
• Bulk purchases (like 25-pound bags) usually give you better value per pound. Yes, it’s a bigger initial investment, but your wallet will thank you later.

Pro Tip: Calculate your coverage needs before buying. Nothing’s worse than running out of bait mid-battle with those furry invaders.

Consider these critical factors:

• Your infestation size (one squirrel or an army?)
• The bait’s effectiveness (cheaper isn’t always better)
• Whether you’re using bait stations (they help reduce waste)

Remember: Skimping on quantity to save a few bucks is like bringing a water pistol to a wildfire. Invest in enough bait to get the job done right the first time.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Does Squirrel Bait Typically Remain Effective Once Placed?

I’ve found that most squirrel baits stay effective for 1-3 days outdoors, though I recommend checking daily. Weather conditions like rain can reduce effectiveness, and I’d replace any bait that gets wet or moldy.

Can Squirrel Baits Attract Unwanted Wildlife Like Raccoons or Birds?

Yes, I’ve found that squirrel baits often attract other wildlife. Raccoons, birds, and even rats will go after these treats. That’s why I recommend using specialized feeders or traps to target squirrels specifically.

Is It Legal to Use Squirrel Bait in Residential Areas?

I recommend checking your local ordinances before using squirrel bait, as regulations vary by area. While it’s often legal to feed squirrels on private property, some cities have restrictions to prevent nuisance wildlife.

What’s the Safe Distance to Place Bait From Vegetable Gardens?

I’ve seen countless gardens destroyed by sneaky squirrels! I recommend placing your bait at least 20-30 feet away from any vegetable garden to keep your produce safe and prevent accidental contamination. Trust me, it’s worth it.

Do Weather Conditions Affect the Effectiveness of Squirrel Baits?

I’ve found that weather definitely impacts bait effectiveness. Rain can wash away scents and soggy bait, while extreme heat may spoil food-based lures. I recommend placing baits during dry, mild conditions for best results.

Last Word

Let’s cut to the chase – squirrel control doesn’t have to drive you up a wall. I’ve shown you the top baits that’ll help you tackle your furry invader problem head-on. Pick the right bait, follow safety protocols, and you’ll be on your way to a squirrel-free property. Just remember: the best bait in the world won’t work if you’re not patient and consistent. Now get out there and reclaim your space!